Pin it
This velvety Amish peanut butter cream pie hits all the right notes with its smooth richness and creamy peanut butter flavor that's become a must-have at our family get-togethers. The super smooth filling tucked into a crisp crust makes an unforgettable treat that never sticks around long when I bring it out.
I stumbled on this gem while touring Amish country in Pennsylvania and I've tweaked it over time. Now my kids ask for it instead of cake whenever their birthdays roll around.
Ingredients
- Prepared 9 inch pie crust: saves time but still tastes homemade if you want that option
- Creamy peanut butter: delivers that standout flavor grab natural kinds for the best taste
- Powdered sugar: cuts the nutty taste with just enough sweetness
- Heavy cream: whipped until it forms peaks gives that cloud-like texture that makes this pie so special
- Vanilla extract: brings extra flavor always go for real not artificial for tastier results
- Cream cheese: adds firmness and a bit of tang against the sweetness
- Milk: creates that perfect easy-to-spread texture
- Whipped cream topping: finishes it off with flair and extra smoothness
- Chopped peanuts: add a nice crunch and make it look fancy
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Create Peanut Butter Base:
- Mix the peanut butter and powdered sugar together in a bowl until you get crumbly bits. This builds the main flavor and the sugar helps lighten up the thick peanut butter.
- Whip The Cream:
- In another bowl beat the heavy cream with vanilla until it stands up in peaks. Don't go too far or you'll end up with butter. Your cream should stay upright when you pull the beaters out.
- Prepare Cream Cheese Mixture:
- Beat the softened cream cheese in a separate bowl until it's totally smooth with no tiny lumps. Slowly pour in milk while beating until everything looks silky. The cream cheese needs to be warm from sitting out or you'll get lumps.
- Combine The Elements:
- Using a spatula, carefully fold the whipped cream into the cream cheese mix with light movements to keep it fluffy. Then gently mix in the peanut butter stuff until you see swirls. Too much mixing will flatten your filling.
- Fill And Chill:
- Pour your filling into the ready pie crust and smooth the top. Cover it loosely with plastic wrap and stick it in the fridge for at least 4 hours but better overnight so it firms up right and the flavors blend together.
Pin it
Getting the cream whipped just right makes all the difference in this pie. I once hurried through this part and ended up with a heavy filling that missed that airy quality that makes everyone love this dessert. My grandma taught me to listen for the sound change as the cream thickens a trick I still count on today.
Storage Tips
Your Amish peanut butter cream pie will stay fresh in the fridge for about 4 days. Keep it in something airtight or wrap it well with plastic to stop it from picking up fridge smells. The filling might get a bit softer after day one but the taste actually gets better with time making this perfect to make ahead.
Flavor Variations
Traditional Amish cooking sticks to straight peanut butter but sometimes I throw in 1/4 cup of melted chocolate chips for folks who can't resist chocolate and peanut butter together. For something different try honey roasted peanut butter or add 1/2 teaspoon of cinnamon to the mix. In summer I sometimes put sliced bananas on the crust before adding the filling for that classic banana and peanut butter combo.
Pin it
Serving Suggestions
Serve this pie cold with extra whipped cream squeezed around the edges and plenty of chopped peanuts on top. For fancy times drizzle some caramel or melted chocolate over each piece right before you serve it. This pie tastes amazing with strong coffee or a glass of cold milk to balance out how rich it is. Want to impress guests? Warm the plates slightly before putting the cold pie on them to bring out more smell.
Historical Context
Amish desserts usually focus on basic fresh ingredients they grow themselves. This no-bake peanut butter pie became popular with Amish families as a summer treat when nobody wanted to heat up the house with an oven. Adding cream cheese is a newer twist on old Amish recipes that first just used fresh cream from their own cows. The Amish love recipes that can feed big families and whole communities which is why this generous pie fits perfectly with how they share meals and celebrate together.
Frequently Asked Questions
- → Is it okay to use a pre-made crust?
Absolutely, using a pre-baked crust from the store saves you time and works just as well.
- → Can I swap creamy for crunchy peanut butter?
Sure, crunchy peanut butter gives a bit of texture, though creamy keeps the filling silky.
- → What's the minimum chilling time?
Let the dessert chill for no less than 4 hours to set perfectly before enjoying.
- → What are some good topping options?
Try whipped cream and chopped nuts, or go bold with caramel sauce or chocolate bits on top.
- → How do I store the leftovers?
Keep any leftovers covered tightly in the fridge for up to 3 days for the best freshness.